As I wait for the Wiki to be updated about combat; let me give some general impressions.
From my understanding in the Tutorial, current wiki and recent patch notes the makers of Starjack are looking for a paper, rock, scissor approach. I see no problem with this besides its unclear how that operations with regard to bigger ships (dreadnoughts, flagships).
Weapons Breakdown
Light - Best for attacking small ships (fighters & corvettes)
Medium - Best for attacking medium ships (destroyers, cruisers, etc)
Heavy - Best for attacking larger ships (dreadnoughts, battleships, flagships)
Artillery - For this discussion its moot because we don't care about bombing planets - we need to get past the fleet first
Now to the RPS (Rock, paper scissor part);
- Light ships (fighers corvettes) should be good at attacking big ships.
- Medium ships (destroyers, cruisers) should be at attacking small ships.
- Big ships (dreadnoughts, battleships and flagships) should be good at attacking medium ships.
This is great in theory but here's the problem I see from the current structure, tonnage. At lower levels you simply can't build big ships at to great of numbers due to tonnage limits. So recently I build big ships to fill up my tonnage then added medium ships to fill it out. I then was informed this isn't the "best" way to do it in-game.
My concern here is that against pirates/enemies that you don't know what your going to face there's very little chance of success besides overwhelming them. This is what the tutorial actually taught you, it gave you the number of ships you needed to build to overwhelm the enemy. But this breaks down as you get to open game play where you have no idea what the enemy has and you deal with tonnage limits. The best solution for a new player is to build the biggest ships you can or build massive numbers of medium/small ships. Neither solution seems very intelligent or well thought out.
So what happens when two equal human players fight? I've actually had 4 space battles with a human so far and 3 more with pirates. The results were completely different. Humans tended to go BIG. As humans we love to build massive ships, throughout history bigger has always been better, even if it wasn't necessary. The pirates on the other hand seem to favor smaller and lighter ships. Their medium ships seem to be extremely powerful against bigger ships. Which according to our RPS shouldn't happen.
Real Life
In real combat situations of WW2 for example, smaller ships (planes) were built with the intention of striking down the home run blows on big capital ships (carriers, battleships etc) while the medium ships roles were to stop the smaller ships from doing this. This left the big ships for destroying the medium ship escorts and their fellow big ships.
Now I understand that's extremely broad statements but that's general thought process and the assumption I think most people will come into StarJack thinking.
A few things that don't line up with that. Medium ships are extremely strong against big ships, doesn't make sense because big ships should be able to target and hit those medium ships. Also big ships current lack the ability to bombard planets. Again why? Big ships are massive, tonnage requirements at TL6 when you first get Flagships require you to spend over 7k of your 10k limit roughly. A ship that BIG should be able to put a gun on it that can shoot down on a planet.
Some Successes
On top of all of this you add the confuse of combat orders to it and furthers makes a mess of combat. Now Starjack is suppose to pride itself on being a 4X game. And let's give credit here, I think the eXplore part is done better then almost any other MMO game of this type. I also think the eXpand and eXploit are done remarkably well with a slight complaint about a bit too much micromanagement.
But right now eXterminate seems to be the least throughout or understand aspect of the game.
Whats the Future?
My suggestion is the following. Committ the game more to RPS described before. Lessen the need for combat orders, we have no clue what we will be fighting, forcing human players to think out every possible force they'll face and adapt orders to it will ruin the game. This can be there for highest level players, but TL1-10 simply don't have time to understand this while trying to figure out the other three X's.
Any thoughts or comments?
|